No Envelope, No Breach and No Safeguard. How Victoria Made its Hotel Policy

By Arthur McInnis
Nov 20, 2026

—————————————————————————————————

Summary: Greater Victoria’s case for 2,000 new hotel rooms, and for the density increases and tax exemption said to be needed to deliver them, came from a working group convened by the hotel industry’s own marketing body. Of its 22 members, 12 were municipal staff, but only the industry members stood to profit, including developers now seeking approvals from the City. The group disclosed no interests, had no independent test of its figures and no seat for residents, heritage or the tax base, and the City then moved on its recommendations. On July 23 Council voted 7 to 2 to direct a tax exemption bylaw for “new hotel development” and waived the public hearing on the density change. Applying three questions I use to identify soft corruption (was it legal, which way did the discretion run, was the safeguard working), the answers are legal, toward the industry, and absent and thus satisfies my test. This finding is about the process itself, not Reliance, Aryze or any individual member of the group.

Every large project needs a reason, and for new hotels in Victoria the reason is a shortage. Greater Victoria, we are told, needs 2,000 new hotel rooms in a decade. Council is told it must clear the way with higher density and a tax exemption. The number is repeated in press releases, in staff reports and, in the developers’, own announcements.


I have written separately about 520 Menzies, the Reliance proposal opposite the Legislature, including its height and density, its heritage setting, the protected views, how the downtown boundary came to include the block, and the tax holiday it may receive. This post leaves the site aside. It asks how the policy behind the hotels was made.


Where does the number come from, and who decided what to do about it? The answer is more uncomfortable than the repetition suggests. The case for new hotels in Victoria was assembled by a group convened by the hotel industry’s own marketing body, with two hotel developers sitting at the table, no disclosure of interests and no independent voice for residents, heritage or the municipal tax base. The City then adopted its main recommendations.

I do not allege that any law was broken. I allege something simpler and, for a municipality, more serious; namely, that the people who stood to gain from a policy were allowed to write the evidence for it, and that the City treated that evidence as if it had come from a neutral source.

A working group, but whose?

The Greater Victoria Hotel Development Working Group was convened by Destination Greater Victoria. That body is the region’s tourism marketing organisation, and it is funded mainly by the three per cent Municipal and Regional District Tax on hotel stays. It is not a committee of Council. It has no terms of reference that the public can read, no published rules for choosing its members, and no obligation to keep minutes in the open.


The City of Saanich’s own description says the group was convened in response to a study that had already identified a need for about 2,000 rooms. Its mandate was to examine barriers to new hotel development. The need was the premise. The only open question was how to remove the obstacles to meeting it.


The final report does not say how members were selected. It does not say who paid for the work. It contains no conflict-of-interest statement and no disclosure of any kind. It says only that member organisations will adopt the recommendations “on their own terms”. Destination Greater Victoria commissioned a supply analysis from Floor13.


A working group that Council had struck would be expected to meet a higher standard. This one met none, and it still became the foundation of City policy.


Who was at the table


The report lists 22 members. By my count, twelve are municipal staff from Victoria, Colwood, Saanich, View Royal, Sooke and Esquimalt. Two are provincial tourism ministry staff. The remaining eight come from the hotel industry, development or lending.  Destination Greater Victoria, the BC Hotel Association, Songhees Development Corporation, CIBC Commercial Banking, Pelan Hospitality, and two developers.


Twelve of 22 is a majority of public-sector staff, so this was not simply an industry body. But the public side was officials, not elected representatives and not residents, and the industry side was the only one with a financial stake in the outcome.

Two of the industry members are the most important. Jon Stovell of Reliance Properties sat on the group. Reliance is the proponent of the 126-room hotel conversion at 780 Blanshard and of the Menzies proposal. Chris Quigley and Luke Mari of Aryze Developments sat on the group. Aryze is Redbrick’s partner on the 198-room Westholme proposal at 603 Pandora, and an Aryze contact is listed on the City’s own pre-application file for that site.

Thus the group that told municipalities how to make hotels easier to build included the companies that are now asking the City to approve hotels.


Who was not at the table


The report names no one from a heritage organisation. It names no one from a neighbourhood association or from the residents who live beside the sites in question. It names no independent economist, no one whose job was to test the demand figures, and no one whose job was to speak for the municipal tax base that a tax exemption would draw on.


The City of Victoria had four seats, the City Manager Jocelyn Jenkyns and Karen Hoese, Alec Johnson and Peter Rantucci. Those four people helped produce a set of recommendations and then, in the months that followed, brought forward proposals to Council that track those recommendations closely. They were not neutral advisers evaluating an outside submission. They were participants in the body that made it.


How fast it moved

The timeline is noteworthy.  The dates for the early steps are drawn from press reports of the time and are approximate.

In the summer of 2025, Destination Greater Victoria announced that it intended to form a task force modelled on those in Vancouver and Alberta. The working group was launched late that year and met five times over six months. Its report was released on April 23, 2026, and it urged action with urgency, describing lower land costs as a generational opportunity that would not last.

In June, Destination Greater Victoria’s vice-president of external relations appeared before Council and told it that the region would not reach its goal without municipal help. In the same month Reliance filed its plans for 780 Blanshard, and Redbrick announced Aryze as its partner on the Westholme. On July 23, by a vote of 7 to 2, Council directed staff to prepare zoning amendments raising non-residential density in the downtown zones and to prepare a revitalization tax exemption bylaw “to support economic revitalization and tourism by spurring investment in new hotel development”. It waived the public hearing for the density amendment, and a motion to require a hearing was defeated 4 to 5 with Councillors Caradonna, Kim, Dell, Loughton and Thompson – the old Gang of Five.


On October 1, sixteen days before the election, the zoning amendments were adopted, and on the same day Council unanimously approved the heritage permit for 780 Blanshard. On October 26 the pre-application file for 520 Menzies was opened. On November 10, two weeks later, the file for 603 Pandora followed. Three hotel applications from members of the group, or their partners, reached the City within a few months of the policy being set.


From launch to Council direction took about eight months. The industry convened the group, the industry’s members reported, the industry’s spokesman presented to Council, and the City moved.


The number that grew


The 2,000-room figure has a history. In 2023, Destination Greater Victoria’s chief executive said downtown needed 400 to 600 rooms within about two years. In November 2024 he said downtown needed 800 to 1,200 rooms, or eight to ten hotels. By 2026 the figure was 2,000 rooms across the region, with 800 said to be absorbable immediately.


The geographies differ, and I do not claim the figures are contradictory. But the headline grew with each iteration, and the City’s own Official Community Plan sets a target of 1,500 new hotel rooms by 2035. The industry’s number is a third higher than the City’s.


There is a real shortage behind this. Room supply has fallen by nearly a quarter since 2016, and occupancy in the summer of 2025 reached roughly 92 per cent. I do not dispute that more rooms are needed. I dispute that a figure produced by the industry, and then cited back by the developers who sat on the group that endorsed it, can be treated as an independent finding. The Redbrick announcement for the Westholme cites the working group’s estimate as part of its justification. The members’ own projects now rely on the group’s figure as evidence of need.

The report itself says it did only a high-level financial analysis and did not assess individual developments. No one has tested whether any particular site, at any particular density, is needed to meet the figure.


What the group recommended, and who gains


The sixth recommendation is for supportive policy and financial tools for hotel conversion and revitalization, including heritage and office conversions. The report proposed that municipalities explore a targeted revitalization tax exemption to encourage reinvestment in aging hotels. It noted that an exemption must take account of its effect on the overall tax base.


Reliance’s 780 Blanshard project is a conversion of a heritage office building. It fits that recommendation exactly. Reliance is doing the same kind of conversion in Vancouver. A developer whose business is converting old office buildings to hotels sat on the group that recommended financial tools for converting old office buildings to hotels.


Then the policy widened. The group’s recommendation was aimed at aging hotels and conversions. City staff described a temporary exemption for new hotels that convert non-residential or heritage buildings and also said an exemption for new hotel construction could close the viability gap, calling the program an investment by the tax-paying community. The motion Council passed on July 23 refers to “new hotel development” and does not limit the exemption to conversions. It sets no term and no conditions. Those will come with the bylaw staff bring back.


Density and the tax exemption multiply each other


Here is a point that I think has been overlooked. The exemption works by holding the municipal tax at the pre-development value, so the hotel does not pay tax on the increase in value that follows from building it. The larger the increase in value, the larger the amount exempted.


What creates the increase in value? Largely the density the City grants. Council directed both measures on the same day, higher density and a tax exemption, and the two multiply each other. Every additional square metre of permitted floor area adds to the value that the exemption then protects. A developer who receives both is paid twice for the same exception, and the second payment comes out of the tax base.


Soft corruption in this story


I use the term “soft corruption” in a particular sense, and I want to apply it to this process and not to any person or company. Soft corruption is legal and it is systemic. That does mean we should either encourage or condone it. It is a system that bends toward insiders because nothing in it prevents that. I use three questions to identify it. Was it legal? Which way did the discretion run? Was there a safeguard and was it working?

Applied to the working group, the first answer is yes. Nothing in the record suggests a breach of any law, and a group convened by a marketing body is not subject to the conflict rules that bind Council.

The second answer is that the discretion ran toward the industry. The City had discretion over whose evidence to rely on and how to shape the policy. It relied on a body whose industry members were the main beneficiaries, widened the exemption from conversions to new development, and waived the public hearing for the density change. I cannot show that the group caused that direction. The City had its own reasons, including a real shortage and its own room target. What I can show is that the direction and the group’s recommendations line up, and that no one separate from the industry tested them.



The third answer is that the safeguards were not working, and the plainer description is that they were absent. There was no independent test of the demand figure, no disclosure of interests, no seat for heritage, residents or the tax base, and City staff sat on both sides of the table. The one public safeguard left at the density stage, a hearing, was waived. The safeguards that remain are the bylaw process still to come and Council’s own deliberation.


Legal, toward the insider, and absent. That is the pattern, and it is a pattern in the process. It says nothing about the intentions of Reliance, Aryze or any other member, who did what the process invited them to do.


What I am not saying


I am not saying Reliance or Aryze did anything improper by sitting on the group. Developers are entitled to take part in industry discussions, and the group’s recommendations bind no one. Reliance has owned 780 Blanshard since 2019 and bought the Menzies property in 2024, so both projects predate the group. Municipal staff were entitled to take part in a regional conversation about hotels.


What I am saying is that the combination fails the tests a public body should meet, and that the failure belongs to the process. The people who benefit sat on the body that produced the evidence. They disclosed nothing. The City’s staff sat on both sides. No independent party tested the figures. And the product was then offered to Council as though it were the considered view of an impartial group. Each of these is defensible alone. Together they describe a process in which the case for a policy and the interests of its beneficiaries were never separated.


What Council should do


Council should not treat the working group’s report as independent evidence of need. It should ask for an analysis of hotel demand and supply from someone with no stake in the result, and it should require that analysis to address the specific sites now before it.


Before the exemption bylaw returns, Council should require the City to say what term and conditions it proposes, whether it covers new construction, and what it would cost the tax base, and should publish that analysis for public comment. The public cannot weigh a density change fairly while the tax benefit attached to it stays unstated.


Council should ask staff to disclose what the City employees sitting on the working group contributed, and whether any declared an interest. It should ask the same of any firm that sat on the group and now appears as an applicant or consultant on a hotel file. The records of the City’s own involvement are the obvious next step for anyone who wants to test this further.


The hotel industry is entitled to advocate for itself. That is what industries do. The City is not entitled to treat that advocacy as neutral advice. Until it is tested by someone with nothing to gain, the case for these hotels rests on an argument written by those who would benefit.


—————————————————————————————————

References


–           CHEK News, “Victoria proposes zoning changes and hotel tax incentive”.

–           City of Victoria Development Tracker, files CLC00490 and CLC00491.

–           City of Victoria, Committee of the Whole minutes, July 23, 2026, item G.2, Economic and Employment Land Solutions.

–           City of Victoria, Victoria 2050 engagement site, Employment Land Initiatives and revitalization tax exemption FAQs.

–           CTV News, report on the Westholme proposal; Victoria Buzz, report on the 780 Blanshard proposal.

–           Destination Greater Victoria, 2025 to 2035 Destination Master Plan and annual reports; Business Examiner and Island Social Trends coverage of the working group.

–           District of Saanich, Hotel Investment Opportunities page, on the group’s convening, mandate and process.

–           Final Report of the Greater Victoria Hotel Development Working Group, April 2026 (as published by the District of Saanich).

–           Times Colonist, “Density change to lure hotels to Victoria won’t include Old Town: city”, “Municipal help needed to meet new-hotel goal: tourism group says”, and “Task force on horizon to speed up hotel development in capital region”.

—————————————————————————————————


See also: Index of articles about lobbying influence on the City of Victoria and deliberations regarding it. – CRD Watch Homepage

Index of Articles regarding Jet Flights for City of Victoria Staff to development lobby events, that were charged to the City. – CRD Watch Homepage

Leave a Reply