Out of the shadows: A key player in B.C.’s controversial housing bills breaks the silence, inadvertently confirming watchdog critiques
A joint investigative analysis by CityHallWatch and CRD Watch
Nov 18, 2026
—————————————————————————————————

Above: New op-ed reveals another of the key players
who wielded a hammer over B.C.’s municipalities
in development of top-down and one-size-fits-all housing legislation.
Photo by Ksenia Chernaya (Pexels.com)
—————————————————————————————————
Starting about four years ago, a suite of sweeping, top-down housing legislation has stripped B.C.’s local governments of much of their zoning authority, eliminated most public hearings for residential rezonings across the province, set long-term municipal urban planning into disarray, and massively upzoned municipalities that have populations over 5,000 residents.
As civic watchdogs we have researched and reported on the lobbying interests that pushed for, influenced, and drove the legislation hammer. Through FOIs and research we could identify many of the players outside the government.
However, it wasn’t always clear who was working within the government to translate the industry lobbying efforts into the sweeping, top-down housing bills, including Bills 43 (2022), 44, 46, and 47 (2023) and others in addition.
On November 12, 2026—just days before Premier-designate Lorne Doerkson and his incoming B.C. Conservative cabinet are to be sworn into office on November 20—one of the primary players within the government who was preparing the legislation finally stepped out from behind the curtain.
In a Vancouver Sun op-ed titled “Why the B.C. government should tread carefully regarding municipal density legislation,” retired civil servant Gord Enemark reveals that in summer 2022, when David Eby was Attorney General and also the housing minister, Enemark was asked to “establish and lead a cross ministry team” to develop a new provincial housing plan, which became B.C.’s 28-point housing plan (Homes for People, April 2023). (Key passages from the op-ed are quoted further below.)
Remarkably, across many thousands of words in hundreds of media articles, and exhaustive Freedom of Information (FOI) investigations published by both CityHallWatch and CRD Watch, Gord Enemark’s name rarely ever surfaced in the public narrative. Until now. The senior official who led housing policy work in the provincial government (from 2018 to 2024, according to his Vancouver Sun bio) operated in the shadows, away from public scrutiny, just as the Province was reshaping the urban fabric of nearly every community in B.C., and rewiring relationships, strengthening the hand of the Province, while weakening the hands of municipalities and their residents.
We must add here that the mainstream media and even well-known political and civic reporters have done a disservice by almost completely turning a blind eye to the role of the UDI and other development lobby influences on the provincial housing legislation. The work of uncovering the connections has largely been left to unpaid civic watchdogs, and even when we publish our findings, reporters rarely cover the revelations. No wonder there is low public awareness of the lobbyists’ efforts that have so warped provincial and municipal legislation and housing policies, and only limited public awareness of how legislative pieces have been put in place.
Now, with the new B.C. Conservative government holding a fresh electoral mandate in 2026, and a Premier-designate who has said he will look at repealing Bill 44 and restoring municipal democracy, Enemark has finally stepped into the public arena to lobby Premier-designate Doerkson to “tread carefully” and preserve the NDP’s legislative framework, one that he helped to create.
Yet in attempting to defend his legacy, Enemark’s first-person account inadvertently validates nearly every major critique that we have raised since 2023. Below this article we provide links to many articles based on FOI revelations where we were piecing together how the legislation was developed.
1. The admissions: What Enemark confirms about the legislative blitz
It was a rushed political sprint, not a collaborative process: Defenders of Bills 44 and 47 have long portrayed the laws as the product of careful, evidence-based work. Enemark’s account suggests otherwise: “Eby soon became premier, and was in a hurry,” he writes, and later, “given the rush, it’s likely that local elected officials weren’t adequately consulted.”
Local democracy was intentionally “sacrificed”: Enemark does not dispute that Bill 44 stripped citizens of their voice. Instead, he frames the abolition of democratic oversight as a deliberate policy feature: “In this case, local input through time consuming public rezoning hearings (generally dominated by those who already own housing) is sacrificed to provide others with more abundant housing options than they now have.” In a single sentence, the former executive director confirms that eliminating public hearings was a calculated trade-off—while dismissing engaged residents as self-interested homeowners. He also uses the “abundant housing” concept, a subtle sign of the influence of the Abundance movement. In his op-ed, he also freely uses the word disparaging term NIMBY, which often signals a general disrespect for local community and neighbourhood concerns—this is a disappointing sign to see coming from an influential policy maker.
Unelected planners bypassed elected councils: While conceding that elected mayors and councillors likely “weren’t adequately consulted,” Enemark notes that “provincial staff did work closely with local government planners, most of whom were receptive.” This confirms what CityHallWatch and CRD Watch documented regarding the rise of a centralized technocracy: provincial bureaucrats and unelected municipal planning staff worked behind closed doors—in some cases bound by Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs)—sidelining elected councils and public accountability.
Designed through a Treasury Board spreadsheet, not urban planning: Enemark’s biography explains the ideological DNA of the legislation. Before running housing policy, Enemark spent nearly a decade (2009–2018) as an executive director in the B.C. Finance Ministry (Treasury Board Staff). He holds a Master’s in Economics, not urban planning or municipal governance. As he explains in his op-ed, his team concluded government couldn’t do it alone “given the expense of building tens of thousands of units of non market housing,” so they chose to “lever the private sector”—in practice, through blanket deregulation. The province’s urban planning overhaul was written by budget economists treating housing and neighbourhoods as financial commodities. The failure to include experts with backgrounds that should be considered essential when developing such sweeping legislation is a serious concern.
2. What Enemark leaves out: The lobbyist pipeline and U.S. templates
While Enemark’s candour about rushing the bills and sacrificing public hearings is revealing, his op-ed is equally notable for what it omits. He portrays his team’s 2022–2023 work as an objective exercise in using “the available research.”
In reality, extensive FOI disclosures uncovered by CRD Watch (index of articles) and policy tracking by CityHallWatch (legislation tracker) reveal a very different origin story:
The Housing Policy Branch and the UDI wish list: While Enemark remained anonymous during his tenure, FOI records obtained by CRD Watch repeatedly exposed the inner workings of the exact unit he led: the Housing Policy Branch. Internal Ministry emails (CRD Watch, FOI) showed officials in March 2021 preparing a ministerial speech for David Eby using a previous Urban Development Institute (UDI) address as the basis, noting “There is a lot of Housing Policy Branch content in there.” Further FOI releases revealed that the UDI—B.C.’s powerful real estate development lobby—was actively lobbying David Eby for mandatory housing targets, pre-zoning, and transit-oriented overrides well before Bills 43, 44, and 47 appeared, and later boasted in its March 2024 newsletter of working directly with the Province to implement Bill 47. Occasionally, Enemark’s name shows up as a target of UDI lobbying. For example, the Lobbyists Registry lists a UDI lobbying activity on October 3, 2022—in the middle of his team’s work on the housing plan—with “Gordon Enemark, Executive Director, Attorney General and Minister responsible for Housing” among the officials lobbied.
The U.S. “Abundance” and YIMBY playbook: Enemark cites UBC economist Thomas Davidoff, Ontario economist Mike Moffatt, and U.S. jurisdictions like Seattle, Portland, and Sacramento in support. He omits that the specific legislative mechanisms embedded in Bills 44 and 47—abolishing single-family zoning, removing public hearings, and enforcing fixed-radius transit overrides—closely mirror U.S. templates (such as California’s SB 9, Oregon’s HB 2001, and Washington’s HB 1110). These policies were aggressively imported into B.C. by local YIMBY groups like Abundant Housing Vancouver (AHV), which was revealed by FOI to have been given the privilege of “expert” designation) and promoted by the Silicon Valley-funded Abundance Network and Seattle’s Sightline Institute. CityHallWatch has covered these connections in detail (see for example, Vancouver’s Villages Plan: Born in the U.S.A.).
Who is lobbying Doerkson today? Notice whom Enemark cites to urge Premier-designate Doerkson to slow down on repealing Bill 44: the Victoria Residential Builders Association, which told him to “pump the brakes,” and the B.C. Real Estate Association. Noticeably absent are tenant advocacy groups, non-profit housing societies, co-op federations, or neighbourhood groups and associations. The chorus urging the new government to keep the NDP’s zoning overrides is led by the exact real estate and construction lobbies that profit from speculative land assembly and reduced public oversight.
3. Deconstructing Enemark’s arguments to the incoming premier
As industry lobbyists and former bureaucrats mobilize to weaken the incoming government’s campaign commitments before cabinet is even sworn in, British Columbians must scrutinize the flawed premises in Enemark’s pitch to Doerkson:
The “always less expensive” fallacy: Enemark writes that “you don’t need to be an economist to know that duplex/fourplex/townhouse units will always be less expensive than single family houses in the same neighbourhood.” This is a classic sleight of hand. Replacing, for example, a $2.4 million detached house with four new strata units priced at $1.5 million each does nothing to solve the affordability crisis for working families, seniors, or renters. Worse, blanket upzoning tends to inflate underlying land values, encouraging the demolition of older homes containing naturally occurring affordable basement suites and secondary rentals.
The federal Housing Accelerator Fund scare tactic: Enemark warns that repealing Bill 44 could jeopardize over $500 million in federal Housing Accelerator Fund (HAF) grants, which require participating communities over 10,000 to allow four units per lot. Rather than surrendering provincial constitutional authority over municipalities to federal funding strings—strings that were themselves lobbied for by the same YIMBY networks—the incoming B.C. government has a clear democratic mandate to renegotiate bilateral infrastructure agreements with Ottawa on terms that respect local governance and actual infrastructure capacity.
The “Bill 43” distraction: Near the end of his column, Enemark offers a subtle bureaucratic pivot: “Perhaps a better place to start would be to revisit Bill 43, the housing targets legislation.” Careful observers should recognize this tactic immediately. By offering up the administrative targets (a.k.a. “naughty lists” of cities deemed to be recalcitrant or laggards) of Bill 43 (the Housing Supply Act, 2022) as a sacrificial lamb, defenders of the status quo hope to protect the real corporate prizes: Bill 44 (blanket province-wide upzoning and the ban on public hearings for most residential rezonings) and Bill 47 (high-density transit-oriented overrides).
4. Our message for Premier-designate Doerkson and the new cabinet
In his closing lines, Enemark recalls meeting Lorne Doerkson at a high school reunion in Prince George five months ago, expressing hope that the incoming premier will keep an “open mind” and listen to “professional advice” rather than “the loudest voices.”
But in a democracy, the “loudest voices” that Enemark dismisses are the voters of British Columbia. They spoke loud and clear, by delivering a decisive electoral mandate for change after experiencing the consequences of top-down legislative overreach. Voters gave a bruising to Eby and his BC NDP party. Doerkson and his party would ignore at his peril the voices demanding change.
When the new cabinet takes office on November 20, it should reject the behind-closed-doors lobbying of the real estate industry and the lobbyists and YIMBY activists who were given back-room and excessive access to policy makers, resulting in the whole suite of housing bills. True housing reform requires:
Repealing the anti-democratic provisions of at least Bills 44 and 47, restoring the right of municipalities and residents to shape their own Official Community Plans and hold transparent public hearings on rezonings and developments affecting them.
Ending the culture of NDAs and secret stakeholder drafting, ensuring full public transparency around who writes provincial legislation. Never forget, public business is the public’s business.
Shifting focus from speculative market deregulation to genuine affordability, prioritizing non-market, cooperative, and purpose-built rental housing paired with real investments in municipal infrastructure, schools, and transit. Take a page from the Housing Reset group, and the writings of housing advocate Leilani Farha (author of Housing Inc., and 2026 CBC Massey Lecturer, a critic of the financialization of housing and proponent of housing as a human right).
Gord Enemark’s decision to step into the spotlight has done British Columbians an unintended service: by admitting that B.C.’s housing laws were rushed, bypassed elected councils, and intentionally sacrificed public hearings, he has provided the clearest possible case for why those laws must be repealed.
—————————————————————————————————
The Hammer in Hindsight:

Photo by Ksenia Chernaya (Pexels.com)
The more we think about this, the more the hammer image is apt to describe the suite of housing legislation introduced under David Eby and the B.C. NDP since 2022.
A prescient article in the Times Colonist made early mention of the hammer in “Oak Bay’s rejection of housing project cited as province eyes taking over approval powers” (25-May-2022). In it, Andrew Duffy wrote, “Housing Minister and Attorney General David Eby has said the government is considering introducing legislation and regulatory changes this fall that could take the final decision-making authority for housing-permit approvals out of the hands of local government. “This is why the province is stepping in — Minister David Eby is saying, come the fall, the hammer’s going to fall,” said Kim Colpman, chief executive at Large & Co., the company that had proposed the Quest building at 2326 Oak Bay Ave.“
CityHallWatch‘s Legislation Tracker (see “The Grand Strategy – The Big Game”) looks at the whole suite of legislation from 2022 to 2026, which began just days after Eby was sworn in as premier of B.C. in November 2022 (not by provincial election, but by acclamation as leader of the ruling BC NDP party, after John Horgan stepped down for health reasons). The suite runs from 2022 (Bill 43, the Housing Supply Act), 2023 (Bills 44, 46, 47), 2024 (Bill 18), and 2025 (Bills 13, 15 and Bill M-216).
In “How an industry-spawned Vancouver-centric ‘YIMBY’ narrative has severely twisted B.C. NDP housing ideology and legislation changes” the hammer imagery comes up again. The opening question posed to B.C.’s Housing Minister Ravi Kahlon by Peter Waldkirch as moderator at the avowed and self-described “YIMBY” activist group Abundant Housing Vancouver’s April 11 (2023) forum, entitled “Refreshing BC’s Housing Strategy with Minister Ravi Kahlon, was “When will your government bring the long-threatened hammer down on local governments that refuse or delay changes to the antiquated inequitable and unaffordable single-family zoning regulations that dominate residential properties within the communities in our province…?“
The hammer image comes back again in “Housing Supply Act is heavy-handed hammer on municipalities, but who are the experts guiding the hand? An FOI query is the only way to find out!” (CityHallWatch, 15-Jun-2023).
And again, when an FOI response finally reveals who are the ten “experts” guiding the provincial hand: “It took 5 months, but B.C. Govt FOI response reveals the ten ‘experts’ guiding the hammer of provincial housing policy” (CityHallWatch, 13-Nov-2023).
That brings us to today and the op-ed by Gord Enemark, which reveals that his was one of the principal hands inside the government that was guiding the legislative hammer.
The underlying thought behind Eby’s housing legislation was the view that elected municipal governments, and their citizens, were the problem, and that the only way to fix the housing crisis is to apply the hammer, top down, in autocratic fashion, with one-size-fits-all legislation and centralization of power and control.
—————————————————————————————————
Related links
CRD Watch – https://crdwatch.ca/
These first two articles are highly relevant. Based on thousands of pages of FOI documents from the government, they reveal how the Urban Development Institute encouraged the provincial government to use a carrot and stick approach against local governments.
Public release of UDI March 10, 2022 presentation slides, agenda, and lobbying letters to David Eby
Freedom of Information reveals that the Province of B.C. was working to implement what the registered lobbying organization, the Urban Development Institute, had been pushing for. This culminated in the recent Housing Bills that override local government authority on zoning.
Next, here are comprehensive indexes of many more articles based on the FOI responses.
Index of articles revealing major lobbying influence on B.C. Provincial Housing Bills and Housing Targets
Index of articles about government use of Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs)
Index of articles regarding lobby events and other meetings between government and lobbyists
Presentation by Sasha Izard to the Special Committee to Review the Lobbyists Transparency Act
The Urban Development Institute lobbied the Province of BC to implement what they called “Global Housing Targets”. The Province would deliver new Housing Bills in response. (RELATED: see the “Opening Doors” MacPhail report below)
The “Hong Kong Model, transit density – Setting expectations and having clear guidance. MDE [Minister David Eby] First step target approach”. UDI Executive Committee Meeting on April 13, 2022 with David Eby when he was the Attorney General and Minister Responsible for Housing
More on Bill 47 (2023) regarding Transit Oriented Areas:
Index of articles regarding proposed plans for Quadra/McKenzie and transit-enabled development upzoning. – CRD Watch Homepage
A brief look at UDI member TransLink and BC Bill 47 (2023) – Sasha Izard
Regarding FOI p. 745 cited above: “As I prepare Minister David Eby’s speech, I will use the previous UDI speech as the basis of content. There is a lot of Housing Policy Branch content in there.” – CRD Watch
More about CRD Watch guest articles: https://cityhallwatch.wordpress.com/guest-writers/sasha-izard-crd-watch/
—————————————————————————————————
CityHallWatch
BC Legislation Tracker – https://cityhallwatch.wordpress.com/legislation-tracker/
Legislation Media Tracker – https://cityhallwatch.wordpress.com/2023/11/10/media-coverage-bills-44-46-47-nov-2023/
Opening Doors (2021). This report is frequently cited and praised by the real estate development industry and by industry-aligned YIMBY activists to justify the top-down B.C. housing legislation brought in by the B.C. NDP starting in 2022. Actually, it should probably be withdrawn or retracted as being exceedingly biased and incomplete. See “Opening Doors” report (Joy MacPhail 2021) underpins B.C. provincial housing policy. But it was biased by industry-aligned supply-side ideologues and that’s a serious problem.
UDI and YIMBY lobbying
How an industry-spawned Vancouver-centric ‘YIMBY’ narrative has severely twisted B.C. NDP housing ideology and massive legislation changes (Bills 44, 46 and 47)
Vaughn Palmer: B.C. NDP drags feet then refuses to release basic info on its housing ‘naughty’ list (Opinion: ‘Cabinet secrecy’ excuse probably masks arbitrary and makeshift decision-making)
The U.S. “Abundance” and YIMBY playbook
Vancouver’s Villages Plan: Born in the U.S.A. – Endgame 2026
More reading
“Reflections on the BC NDP housing policy, modelling, and analysis” (19-Dec-2023): Former BC Green’s MLA Adam Olsen provides what is still one of the most incisive and extensive articles to date regarding three pieces of housing-related legislation (Bills 44, 46, and 47) enacted by the B.C. NDP in 2023. How do the BC Greens today view this and subsequent legislation?
‘After leading the opposition to Bill 44, Burnaby is ready to work together on a better approach to housing’ (Mayor Mike Hurley) (with introduction and annotation by CityHallWatch, 16-Nov-2026)
—————————————————————————————————
Key passages from Enemark’s op-ed
The excerpts below are the passages this analysis relies on, from Gord Enemark’s November 12, 2026 Vancouver Sun op-ed, “Why the B.C. government should tread carefully regarding municipal density legislation.” The full column is available at that link (print edition, November 12, 2026, page 7).
In summer 2022, when I was executive director at the Ministry of Attorney General’s housing policy branch, I was asked to establish and lead a cross ministry team to develop a new provincial housing plan. By then, B.C.’s housing crisis was a given. David Eby, then attorney general, was also the housing minister and wanted bold actions.
Eby soon became premier, and was in a hurry. We knew we were 20 years getting into this crisis and that it would take over a decade to get out of it. B.C. needed, and still needs, much more supply, and housing policy branch staff felt we had to “lever the private sector” to make a meaningful difference. Government couldn’t do this alone, given the expense of building tens of thousands of units of non market housing.
Using the available research, we developed a cabinet approved 28 point housing plan, released in April 2023. Its two cornerstones became Bill 44 (whereby residential property owners in municipalities over 5,000 would have the right to build three to six units without rezoning hearings if there is compliance with the official community plan) and Bill 47 (which allows for much higher densities in 104 transit oriented areas in 31 municipalities.)
Gord Enemark, Vancouver Sun, Nov 12, 2026
The Victoria Residential Homebuilders Association recently released a statement that provided the following advice to Doerkson: “He needs to pump the brakes … Bill 44 has increased missing middle homes 47 per cent (townhomes, duplexes, small multis), which are critical for young families in Greater Victoria.” The B.C. Real Estate Association is also recommending the new government carefully consider its actions on Bills 44 and 47.
Another consideration is that federal housing accelerator fund grants could also be at risk, since to be eligible, communities over 10,000 must commit to zoning that allows at least four units per property — and at this time over $500 million has been approved for B.C., most of it for 19 larger B.C. municipalities.
To the doubters, I would say that you don’t need to be an economist to know that duplex/ fourplex/townhouse units will always be less expensive than single family houses in the same neighbourhood. And what most families need is “ground oriented” housing, not condo units 10 storeys high.
But like any policy choice, there are trade offs. In this case, local input through time consuming public rezoning hearings (generally dominated by those who already own housing) is sacrificed to provide others with more abundant housing options than they now have. And yes, over the next few decades many neighbourhoods would have incrementally more “infill” density.
None of this is to say that Bill 44 couldn’t be improved, and given the rush, it’s likely that local elected officials weren’t adequately consulted. But provincial staff did work closely with local government planners, most of whom were receptive.
Perhaps a better place to start would be to revisit Bill 43, the housing targets legislation — municipalities already know they need much more housing.
Gord Enemark, Vancouver Sun, Nov 12, 2026
Now, with Doerkson’s new role as premier comes the responsibility of making policy not just by listening to the loudest voices, but also by considering evidence and professional advice, including on the critical housing file.
Back to Doerkson: My sense from our conversation in June was also that he has an open mind. This is an early chance to use it in a way that will benefit the next generation of British Columbians in a tangible way.
Gord Enemark, Vancouver Sun, Nov 12, 2026
—————————————————————————————————
See also: Index of articles regarding Law and Bylaw – CRD Watch Homepage
Petition · Repeal (or amend) BC Bill 44 to Restore Public Hearings and Municipal Powers over Zoning. – Canada · Change.org

Leave a Reply